Why You Can’t 'Try' Your Way Into Grace (DNA of Grace)

Have you ever felt like you were running a race on a treadmill that keeps speeding up? You are panting, sweating, and giving it every ounce of energy you have, yet you aren't actually moving forward. In fact, the harder you run, the more exhausted you become, and the further the "finish line" seems to drift away.

For years, many of us have approached our relationship with God this way. We call it "growth" or "discipleship," but if we are honest, it feels a lot more like a performance review. We think that if we just pray a little longer, read a few more chapters, or "try harder" to be a better person, then God will finally be pleased with us.

However, the reality is that Why You Can’t 'Try' Your Way Into Grace is the most important lesson you will ever learn. If you are exhausted by your own efforts, I have good news for you today. You were never meant to power your life through pressure. This article is a "spoke" to our main teaching hub, and you can find the deep dive on this topic at This Is Why Trying Isn’t Working.

Specifically, when we talk about the "DNA of Grace," we have to address the performance-based Christianity that has infected so many of our hearts. We want to do right. We love God. But we often fall into the trap of thinking our behavior determines our standing. Consequently, we spend our lives striving for an acceptance we already have.

I spent over 50 years in ministry, and for a long time, I lived in this cycle. I didn't become legalistic because I hated grace; I became legalistic because I loved God and was afraid of losing Him. I thought "trying" was evidence of my devotion. But trying is often just a polite word for self-reliance.

If you are working for it, it isn't grace, it’s a paycheck. And God isn't looking to be your employer; He wants to be your Father.

Why does "trying harder" always seem to fail in the long run? Why do we find ourselves back in the same ruts of frustration and guilt? Here are three reasons why performance-based striving can never produce the life of Christ in you.

When you are "trying," your eyes are glued to your own performance. You are checking your spiritual pulse every five minutes. You are wondering, "How am I doing today? Did I do enough? Was my prayer sincere enough?" Meanwhile, the focus has shifted entirely away from the Finished Work of Jesus. Grace is about what He did; trying is about what you are doing. Therefore, the more you try, the less you trust.

Performance-based living requires a scorecard. You need to know if you’re winning or losing. This creates a culture of comparison and fear. If you have a "good day," you feel proud. If you have a "bad day," you feel condemned. As a result, your peace is tied to your consistency rather than God’s character. But as I often say, "God is not disappointed in you. He is not measuring your worth by your consistency."

This is the hardest truth to swallow. When we try to add our effort to God’s grace to make ourselves "acceptable," we are essentially saying that what Jesus did wasn't enough. We are trying to finish a work that He already declared was "Finished." If you could "try" your way into God's favor, Jesus wouldn't have needed to die.

So, if trying isn't working, what do we do? Do we just quit? No. We don't quit the Christian life; we change the power source. We move from the "flesh" (our effort) to the "Spirit" (His life in us). Here are three shifts you can make right now to stop striving and start living.

Instead of asking, "What must I do for God today?" start asking, "What has God done for me?" Practice being aware of His presence rather than evaluating your performance. You are already accepted. You are already loved. You are already "in Christ." When you focus on His presence, the pressure to perform begins to melt away.

Most of us think rest is the reward for a job well done. In the Kingdom of God, rest is the requirement for the work to begin. You cannot live the life of Christ until you rest in the love of God. Remember this: "Rest doesn't come after you fix yourself. Rest comes first."

He doesn't say, "Come to me when you’ve finished your chores." He says, "Come to me because you are tired."

A servant works to keep his job. A son works because he shares his father’s heart. Your identity is not "worker"; your identity is "beloved child." When you know you are a son or daughter, you don't work for love; you work from love. This is a massive distinction. Loved people become loving people. It is the natural overflow of a secure heart.

The hardest part of this journey is actually believing it. We are so conditioned to believe that "there is no such thing as a free lunch" that we struggle to accept a free salvation and a free life of grace. We think there must be a catch.

But there is no catch. There is only a Cross.

To truly stop "trying" and start "trusting," you have to take what I call The Big Leap of Faith: Believing God Loves You Exactly As You Are. This isn't a leap into the dark; it’s a leap into the arms of a Father who has been following you with mercy your entire life.

I remember sitting in a doctor's office after being told I had Stage 4 Kidney Cancer. In that moment, all my "trying" meant nothing. I couldn't "try" my way out of cancer. I couldn't "try" my way into more years of life. All I could do was rest. And in that rest, I found a peace that performance could never give me. These tumors were not bigger than God’s grace, and neither is your struggle.

As we wrap up Part 7 of our DNA of Grace series, I want you to take a deep breath. You are not behind. You are not being graded. You are being held.

The Christian life was never meant to be powered by fear, pressure, or performance. It was meant to be lived from a place of being loved first. When you stop trying to get to God, you realize He has already come to you. He is not waiting for you to get your act together. He is waiting for you to let Him be the strength you don't have.

If you want to dive deeper into this and hear more about the "Rest" that changes everything, I encourage you to check out our main hub article: This Is Why Trying Isn’t Working. It will give you the scriptural foundation you need to finally hop off the treadmill of performance.

It is a gift. You don't "try" for a gift. You just open your hands and receive it.

If this message resonated with you, please check out the Followed By Mercy podcast at https://followedbymercy.buzzsprout.com. We talk about these truths every week, helping you move from the weight of religion to the wonder of grace. You can also find us on YouTube at @waustingardner for more teaching and mentoring.

God’s mercy is after you right now, ready to bring real grace and honest hope. Stop trying. Start trusting. Rest in Him today.

If I stop "trying," does that mean I just do whatever I want?
Actually, it means you start doing what God wants, but from a different motivation. When you realize how much you are loved, you naturally want to please the One who loves you. It’s not about being "lawless"; it's about being "love-led."

How do I know if I am "striving" or just being "diligent"?
The key is the "fruit" in your heart. Striving produces anxiety, exhaustion, and a fear of failure. Diligence in grace produces joy, peace, and a sense of partnership with God. If you feel "heavy," you are likely striving.

What if I feel like I've failed too many times for grace to apply?
Grace is specifically designed for failures. You cannot "out-fail" the Finished Work of Jesus. His mercy isn't trailing behind you with conditions; it is running toward you with intention.

#Grace #IdentityInChrist #DNAofGrace #AustinGardner #FollowedByMercy